Open the About page of a two-year-old D2C brand and the odds are decent you’ll find a line about “time-honoured recipes,” a founder’s grandmother, or a process “perfected over generations.” The company was incorporated after 2022. Nobody’s grandmother ran a factory. The copy is doing a job the business hasn’t actually done yet, which is accumulate the kind of time that makes a claim like that true.

This isn’t dishonesty in the legal sense - most of it is technically defensible if you squint, a recipe really did come from somewhere, a process really was inspired by something old. But it’s a category-wide tell that founders have reached for the language of heritage before they’ve put in the years that language is supposed to represent, and customers are getting better at noticing the gap between the two.

Heritage is a claim about time, and time can’t be shortcut

Every other brand attribute - quality, design, even trust in the short run - can be built quickly with enough focus and money. Heritage is the one claim that is definitionally about duration. A brand either has been doing the thing for a long time or it hasn’t, and no amount of copywriting changes which one is true. That’s exactly why it gets borrowed so often: it’s one of the few positioning levers that can’t be bought, so founders try to simulate it with language instead.

The simulation usually takes one of three forms - a founder’s family story stretched to imply the company inherited something rather than started it, manufacturing language borrowed from craft traditions the company has no actual relationship to, or a vague appeal to “Indian tradition” broad enough that it can’t be fact-checked against anything specific. All three read as filler to anyone who’s seen the pattern before, which by now is most of the customer base that reads About pages at all.

What the brands with real heritage actually do

The companies that genuinely have decades behind them tend to undersell the fact, not oversell it. A spice brand with a real sixty-year history will mention the year almost in passing, point to something concrete - a specific supplier relationship held since a specific decade, a packaging detail that predates the founder’s own involvement - and move on to what the product does today. Confidence about a real asset doesn’t need adjectives stacked on top of it. The adjectives show up precisely when the underlying fact is thin.

That’s the tell worth training a founder’s ear to catch in their own copy: if a sentence about heritage needs words like “legacy,” “time-honoured,” or “generations” to carry it, and the company can’t name the specific year, person, or decade the claim refers to, the sentence is doing persuasion work a real history wouldn’t need.

What to claim instead, if the company doesn’t have decades yet

A young brand’s honest alternative to borrowed heritage is specificity about what it actually has - a founder’s genuine background in the category, a sourcing decision made for a real and statable reason, a process detail that’s true and checkable rather than evocative and vague. “We’ve been testing this formulation since 2023 and changed it four times before shipping” is a less grand sentence than “perfected over generations,” and it’s also one a customer can believe, because nothing in it is asking to be taken on faith. Heritage, when a brand doesn’t have it yet, isn’t a gap to paper over with tone. It’s just a chapter that hasn’t been written, and the honest move is to write the chapter that’s actually true so far.