Ask a certain kind of founder what they’re building and they’ll say some version of: “we’re not really in [existing category] - we’re creating a new one.” It sounds ambitious. It photographs well in a pitch deck. It is, in most cases, a way to avoid the harder and less flattering work of explaining why a customer should pick this product over the three others already sitting in a category they already understand.
Why the move is so tempting
Category creation promises a clean field. No competitors to be compared against, no existing expectations to meet or subvert, no customer walking in with an opinion already formed. It also promises outsized returns - the handful of real category creators get remembered as the category, not a player in it.
The catch is that genuine category creation takes years of customer education most startups cannot fund, and nearly all the companies now cited as proof it works were not trying to create a category when they started. They were solving a specific, narrow problem well enough that a label got attached to them later, by journalists and analysts, after the fact.
What’s usually happening instead
A founder declares a new category because positioning inside the obvious one is uncomfortable. It requires naming a real competitor, admitting a real tradeoff, and picking a specific customer to serve well instead of everyone who might plausibly buy. “We’re inventing something new” sidesteps all three questions. It’s a positioning statement wearing a strategy’s clothes.
The cheaper, less glamorous move
Name the category customers already use to search for a solution. Say, specifically, what this product does better than the two or three things customers are already comparing it to, and what it deliberately does worse or doesn’t do at all. That sentence is less exciting in a deck. It’s also the sentence that gets repeated correctly by a salesperson, a customer, and a journalist, because it doesn’t require anyone to first accept an entirely new frame before they can understand the pitch.
The category gets created later, if it gets created at all - usually by someone else, writing about a company that was busy being specific.